PRECIOUS Nkunika, the judiciary stores officer who was jailed five years on Tuesday for stealing a baby at University Teaching Hospitals(UTH) has appealed against the jail term.
Ms Nkunika, 28, has filed the appeal together with her mother , Grace Siska, who was given a lesser two year jail term for harbouring the stolen baby.
Ms Nkunika and her mother argue that the Lusaka Magistrate’s Court erred in law and fact when it jailed them.
In their notice of appeal against the judgement, they argue that the learned magistrate, Crispin Hampungani, erred in law and in fact when he found that Siska harboured Ms Banda’s baby when there was no such evidence before the court.
The appallents further argue that the magistrate erred in law and in fact when he relied on uncorroborated and discredited testimony of a single identifying witness that Nkunika is the one who received the baby from D-Block.
“The learned trial magistrate erred in law and in fact when he held that people are now afraid to give birth in hospitals because they are afraid that their children will be stolen as the basis of passing long sentences when there was no such evidence before the court,” the notice reads.
They submit in their eight grounds of appeal that the magistrate when he convicted Nkunika of child stealing when no witness saw her stealing the said child.
They further submit that the learned trial magistrate erred in law and in fact when it held that the baby in question belonged to Madalitso Banda when there was no evidence before the court to prove that the said child belonged to, or was ever in the custody of Madalitso Banda,” the document reads.
They add that the magistrate erred when he relied on hearsay evidence as the basis of the truth on which it convicted the appellants, contrary to settled rules and principles of evidence.
They submit that ,the appellants add that the magistrate erred when he relied on the testimony obtained by the police from the appellants, without a warn and caution.
The appallents further contend that the learned magistrate erred in law and in fact when he found that Siska harboured Ms Banda’s baby when there was no such evidence before the court.
Through their lawyers, Malisa and Partners Legal Practitioners, the appallent are reportedly schedule to file bail pending appeal.
Nkunika was jailed alongside UTH employee Emily Hall, a 37-year-old nutrition demonstrator of Kabwata Estates, and Rabecca Mkandawire, 42, a maid, of Bauleni Township.
Nkunika and the UTH workers were found guilty of child stealing while Siska was convicted for harbouring the stolen baby.
The offences were committed on May 7, 2022, after the recuperating mother of the stolen baby, Madaliso Banda, was moved from Kafue General Hospital to UTH for specialist treatment.
The convicts denied the allegations and the state called 13 witnesses, among them doctors, nurses, police officers, and family members.
During trial, Farrai Chiyenge, a physician who referred Ms Banda to UTH, narrated that women had suffered from HIE during delivery which also affected her male baby.
Ms Banda was then referred to UTH for specialist treatment with her baby who was stolen from D-Block.
When Ms Banda was taken to UTH, it was during the same period that Nkunika was at the same hospital where she had been delivered of a one kilogramme premature baby girl but it died.
Evidence is that the other convicts from promised to organise a baby for Nkunika and that K3, 500 was paid for the same.
The court also heard that Nkunika informed some neighbours that she was delivered of twins but one of them died and she remained with one.
A crime scene officer at Kabwata Police Station also narrated that she interrogated Nkunika who admitted being in custody of the baby who was found at Siska’s house.
In the judgement, magistrate Hampungani found that it was a fact that Nkunika connived with the other UTH workers to steal the male baby after her female infant died.
(Mwebantu, Thursday, May 9th, 2024)